The unmodified remainder is not a good sentence because it is very unbalanced. There are 22 words in the subject part of the sentence, and only 7 in the verb and complement. This makes the reader feel that the sentence has been broken off prematurely.

There are two solutions:

Throughout the cold war, the Baltic States, stoically remained parts of the Soviet Union, recognizing the futility of asserting their independence against the overwhelming strength of the Red Army.

Here the parenthetic clause describing the subject has become an adverbial explaining why they stoically remained. This is balanced because there is a semantic parallel between the verb and complement phrase and the elements of the adverbial.

stoically remained

parts of the Soviet Union

recognizing the futility of asserting their independence against

the overwhelming strength of the Red Army

 

The other solution is to shift this adverbial to the start of the sentence:

Recognizing the futility of asserting their independence against the overwhelming strength of the Red Army, the Baltic States, stoically remained parts of the Soviet Union throughout the cold war.

Personally, I prefer this as the pronoun ('their') preceding the noun it denotes ('the Baltic States') creates great momentum, as the reader needs to get to the noun to comprehend the first part of the sentence. Furthermore, the full stop after 'throughout the cold war' seems to dramatise the end of that period of history. One can easily imagine the beginning of the next sentence, 'However, with the collapse of the Berlin Wall and the dissolution of the Warsaw Pact, politicians in Vilnius, Riga and Tallin began... '

 

Do you have a document that needs checking, editing or rewriting? Make sure your work is in perfect, effective English. Click here for our editing and proofreading services.

 

Redundancy Reduction Techniques

Now we have seen how a sentence can be built up from its elemental clauses, we can examine three basic techniques to reduce redundancy.

  1. The elimination of 'there is/are'
  2. The conversion of passive verb forms into noun phrases
  3. The replacement of pronouns

Techniques 1 and 2 are directly linked to the previous exercise because they produce the type of elemental clauses that we have been using to build sentences.

  1. The elimination of 'there is/are'
  2. This is as easy as it sounds. In a first draft, a sentence such as,

    'There are three Baltic States, Latvia, Lithuania and Estonia'

    can be simply made into a subject in the second draft -

    The Baltic States, Latvia, Lithuania and Estonia, recognized the futility of asserting their independence against the overwhelming strength of the Red Army.

  3. The conversion of passive verb forms into noun phrases

As we have seen, a passive sentence, such as

The motion was carried by a majority of two to one.

can be converted into a noun phrase -

The two to one majority in favour of the motion...

Here is another example:

Passive verb forms can be converted into noun phrases.

can be converted into

The conversion of passive verb forms into noun phrases...

Convert the following into noun phrases:

  1. The plan was formulated.
  2. The proposal was rejected.
  3. The island was transformed from a penal colony into a tourist centre.
  4. The document has been edited.
  5. The symphony was composed between 1907 and 1909.

Click here for the answers.

Course Contents / Academic Editing Service

© 2002 Martin Paterson